| |

 |
On the South Asian
Tragedy
Winter 2004 |
On January 7th, Congress passed legislation allowing Americans to
deduct from their 2004 tax returns any
tsunami relief donations they make by
the end of the month. Normally,
taxpayers must take deductions in the
year they make donations, but the
unprecedented change allows them to
forgo a year’s wait. This amnesty will
increase the amount that Americans
donate to agencies supplying
emergency relief to victims of the
Christmas Day tsunami in the Indian
Ocean, and Congress’s decision to
encourage aid in the form of private
donations is a fundamentally
American gesture.
Equally telling is the role of the United
States military in the relief effort. As
reported by conservative writer Mark
Steyn and many others, the U.S. Navy,
Marine Corps, and Air Force have taken
the lead in providing food, clean water,
medical care, and other necessities to
the tsunami survivors, especially in
Indonesia and Sri Lanka. The aircraft
carrier USS Abraham Lincoln was sent to
the Indian Ocean shortly after the
disaster and has since served as a mobile
base of operations, dispatching
helicopters to airlift supplies to
devastated areas. In concert with
Australian, Singaporean, Indian, and
Japanese forces, American military
engineers have rebuilt destroyed water
systems and schools.
Hundreds of thousands of South Asians
owe their lives to the fast action of the
American military, especially in light of
the fact that U.N. relief efforts only began
two full weeks after the tragedy. Yet the
United States’ leadership throughout the
initial relief effort has not kept the United
Nations from claiming American relief
work as its own in disingenuous press
releases and conferences. Responding to
U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan’s
claim that the American-led coalition
“will be in support of the efforts that the
U.N. is leading,” Steyn writes: “American
personnel in American planes and
American ships will deliver American
food and American medicine and
implement an American relief plan, but
it’s still a ‘U.N.-led effort.’”
U.S. economic and military might is
saving lives in South Asia. The tax
deduction rule change and the militaryled
effort in South Asia both embody the
American rejection of centralized
authority in the distribution and
deployment of resources. Instead of
extending deductions, Congress could
have raised taxes and then funded more
tsunami relief directly. By allowing
individual taxpayers to decide for
themselves how to donate, however,
Congress likely made sure that at least
as much relief money would be provided.
More importantly, individual donors can
better scrutinize relief agencies and
participate in other charitable
organizations with the wherewithal to
examine would-be relief providers for
efficiency and corruption. In this way,
economic decisions are devolved to the
individual, though he frequently finds it
most fitting to cooperate with others. This
devolution is responsible for our
unprecedented prosperity.
Fortunately for the tsunami victims,
the U.S. has consistently refused to
relinquish sovereignty over its military
affairs to the U.N. Our
disproportionately high military
spending allows us to project our
power far more effectively than any
country on the globe. This focus on
defense gives us the ability to set up
fast, efficient supply lines and effective
logistics coordination. By comparison,
Canada has a 600-ton disaster relief
unit that would be very helpful to the
relief effort … if they only had the airlift
capability to transport it (The Canadian
Air Force has exactly 4 CC-150 Polaris
transport planes, each with a capacity
of 13 tons).
U.S. military funding and
deployment do not hinge on orders
from on high, and neither does the U.S.
economy. Consequently, hundreds of
thousands of people in South Asia will
survive.
|